
What an Affirmative Defense Is
Most criminal defenses argue that the prosecution cannot prove what happened. An affirmative defense works differently. It says that even if the accused did the act, the law excuses or justifies it, such as using force to stop an attack or acting under a threat of violence.
Colorado recognizes a number of affirmative defenses, and the rules for each are set by statute. Some apply to almost any charge, while others are limited to particular situations or offenses.
This guide explains how affirmative defenses work in Colorado, the burden of proof, and the requirements for the defenses that come up most often in El Paso County and the surrounding counties.
On This Page
- How the Burden of Proof Works
- Defenses That Are Not Affirmative Defenses
- Self-Defense and Defense of Others
- Defense of a Home: The Make My Day Law
- Duress
- Entrapment
- Choice of Evils
- Involuntary Intoxication
- Insanity
- Other Affirmative Defenses
- How Affirmative Defenses Are Raised and Tried
- Working With a Colorado Springs Defense Lawyer
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Sources
How the Burden of Proof Works
The burden rule is the most important thing to understand about affirmative defenses in Colorado. It is set out in C.R.S. 18-1-407.
Step One: Raising the Defense
The defense must be raised by “some credible evidence.” That evidence can come from the prosecution’s own case, such as a witness who describes the alleged victim swinging first, or from defense witnesses, physical evidence, or the accused’s testimony. This is a low threshold, and the judge decides whether it has been met.
Step Two: The Prosecution Must Disprove It
Once the defense is raised, the prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defense does not apply, in addition to proving every element of the crime. The jury is instructed on the defense, and if the jurors have a reasonable doubt about it, they must acquit.
The accused never has to prove the defense. That is a significant advantage compared with some other states, where the defendant must prove certain defenses by a preponderance of the evidence.
Defenses That Are Not Affirmative Defenses
Not every defense is an affirmative defense. Alibi and mistaken identity, for example, are arguments that the prosecution has not proven the accused committed the act. They do not get an affirmative defense instruction because they challenge the elements directly.
Self-Defense in Reckless and Negligent Crimes
Self-defense is an affirmative defense to crimes that require intent or knowledge. For crimes that require only recklessness, extreme indifference, or criminal negligence, such as reckless second-degree assault, Colorado treats it differently.
Under C.R.S. 18-1-704(4), the accused may still present evidence of self-defense, and the jury is instructed on the law of self-defense. The jury can consider it in deciding whether the accused acted recklessly or negligently, but the prosecution does not carry the extra burden of disproving self-defense. How a charge is filed can therefore change the strength of a self-defense claim.
Voluntary Intoxication
Voluntary intoxication is not a defense. Evidence of intoxication may be offered to show the accused could not form a specific intent, when specific intent is an element, but it does not apply to crimes requiring only knowing conduct.
Self-Defense and Defense of Others
Self-defense is the affirmative defense raised most often in Colorado, usually in assault, menacing, and homicide cases. Under C.R.S. 18-1-704, a person may use physical force to defend themselves or a third person from what they reasonably believe is the use or imminent use of unlawful physical force.
The force used must be the degree the person reasonably believes is necessary. The standard is what a reasonable person would believe in the same situation, not what turned out to be true.
Deadly Physical Force
Deadly physical force is justified only if a lesser degree of force is reasonably believed to be inadequate and the person reasonably believes they or another person face imminent danger of being killed or receiving great bodily injury. The statute also allows deadly force against someone using or about to use physical force against an occupant during a burglary, or committing or about to commit kidnapping, robbery, sexual assault, or certain assaults.
When Self-Defense Is Not Available
- Provocation. The person provoked the use of force with intent to cause injury or death.
- Initial aggressor. The person started the fight, unless they withdrew, clearly communicated that withdrawal, and the other person continued.
- Combat by agreement. The force came from a fight both people agreed to that was not authorized by law.
- Bias-based force. The force was based on the other person’s actual or perceived gender, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation, including after a nonforcible romantic or sexual advance.
Colorado courts have held that a person who is not the initial aggressor generally has no duty to retreat before using force in self-defense. Whether the accused was the initial aggressor is often the central factual dispute in these cases.
Defense of a Home: The Make My Day Law
Colorado’s “Make My Day” law, C.R.S. 18-1-704.5, gives extra protection to people defending their homes. An occupant of a dwelling may use any degree of physical force, including deadly force, against a person who has made an unlawful entry into the dwelling, when the occupant reasonably believes all of the following:
- the intruder has committed or intends to commit a crime in the dwelling, in addition to the unlawful entry; and
- the intruder might use any physical force, no matter how slight, against an occupant.
An occupant who meets these requirements is immune from criminal prosecution and from civil liability.
The Pretrial Immunity Hearing
Because the statute grants immunity from prosecution, not just a defense at trial, an accused can ask the court to dismiss the case before trial. In People v. Guenther (1987), the Colorado Supreme Court held that the accused must prove the immunity requirements by a preponderance of the evidence at that hearing. If the motion is denied, the accused can still raise the defense at trial, where the prosecution must disprove it beyond a reasonable doubt.
Limits
The law applies only to an unlawful entry into a dwelling. It generally does not cover people invited into the home, confrontations in a yard or driveway, or businesses, though ordinary self-defense may still apply in those situations. Prison and jail housing is excluded by statute.
Duress
Under C.R.S. 18-1-708, a person is not guilty of an offense, other than a class 1 felony, if they acted at another person’s direction because of the use or threatened use of unlawful force against them or someone else, and a reasonable person in their situation could not have resisted.
Courts generally require a specific and imminent threat, not a vague fear of future harm. The defense is not available to a person who intentionally or recklessly placed themselves in a situation where it was probable they would be subjected to that kind of force.
Duress comes up in cases where someone was forced to drive, carry drugs, or take part in a theft by a partner or associate. Evidence of threats, prior violence, and the absence of a safe way out is important in these cases.
Entrapment
Under C.R.S. 18-1-709, conduct is not criminal if the accused was induced to commit it by a law enforcement officer, or someone working at an officer’s direction, using methods that created a substantial risk that the offense would be committed by a person who would not otherwise have committed it.
The statute also sets an important limit: merely giving a person an opportunity to commit a crime is not entrapment, even when officers use tactics meant to overcome the person’s fear of getting caught. Colorado courts focus on whether the accused was already predisposed to commit the offense.
Entrapment is raised most often in undercover drug cases, prostitution stings, and online investigations. The written messages between the accused and the officer or informant are usually the key evidence. See our drug crimes page and our post on solicitation and prostitution charges.
Choice of Evils
The choice of evils defense, sometimes called necessity, is found in C.R.S. 18-1-702. Conduct that would otherwise be a crime is justified when it was necessary as an emergency measure to avoid an imminent public or private injury that was about to occur through no conduct of the accused.
The threatened injury must be serious enough that, by ordinary standards of intelligence and morality, avoiding it clearly outweighs the harm the criminal statute is meant to prevent. The defense cannot be based on disagreement with the law itself.
Before the jury hears this defense, the judge must decide as a matter of law whether the facts offered, if proven, would amount to a justification. Courts apply the defense narrowly. Examples include driving without a license to get someone to a hospital in a true emergency.
Involuntary Intoxication
Under C.R.S. 18-1-804(3), a person is not criminally responsible if, because of intoxication that was not self-induced, they lacked the capacity to conform their conduct to the law. Unlike voluntary intoxication, it is a complete defense.
Intoxication is not self-induced when the person did not know, and should not have known, that a substance could intoxicate them, or when they took a substance under medical advice. Common examples include being drugged without one’s knowledge and an unexpected reaction to medication taken as prescribed.
These cases often depend on toxicology, medical records, and testimony from a pharmacologist or physician. Evidence should be gathered quickly, because blood and urine samples may not be kept for long.
Insanity
Under C.R.S. 16-8-101.5, a person is legally insane if a mental disease or defect made them incapable of distinguishing right from wrong with respect to the act, or prevented them from forming a culpable mental state that is an element of the crime. Conditions caused by voluntary intoxication, and motives such as anger or revenge, do not qualify.
A plea of not guilty by reason of insanity is generally entered at arraignment, and it triggers a court-ordered sanity examination. Every person is presumed sane, but once evidence of insanity is introduced, the prosecution must prove sanity beyond a reasonable doubt under C.R.S. 16-8-105.5.
A finding of not guilty by reason of insanity is not a release. The person is committed to the Colorado Department of Human Services for treatment until a court finds they are eligible for release. A 2025 law changed how and where sanity examinations are conducted, but it did not change the definition of insanity.
Other Affirmative Defenses
Colorado law includes several other affirmative defenses that apply in specific situations:
- Withdrawal from complicity. A person charged as an accomplice who ended their involvement before the crime and gave timely warning to police or the intended victim. See our post on complicity and accessory charges.
- Renunciation of a conspiracy. A person who thwarted the success of the conspiracy under circumstances showing a complete and voluntary renunciation of criminal intent.
- Execution of public duty. Conduct required or authorized by law, such as a court order.
- Use of force by people with special responsibilities. Parents, teachers, and others in limited situations.
- Offense-specific defenses. Many statutes include their own defenses, such as a human trafficking defense to prostitution charges.
How Affirmative Defenses Are Raised and Tried
Raising an affirmative defense is a strategic decision. No lawyer can promise a particular result, and these defenses carry trade-offs that need careful thought.
Notice to the Prosecution
Colorado’s discovery rules generally require the defense to tell the prosecution before trial about defenses it intends to raise. Insanity has its own formal plea and examination process.
Admitting the Act
Most affirmative defenses accept that the act happened and argue that it was justified or excused. That can be inconsistent with other defenses, such as identity, and the choice should be made after the evidence has been fully reviewed.
Testimony and Evidence
Self-defense and duress cases often depend on what the accused perceived at the moment, which may require the accused to testify. Witness statements, 911 recordings, injury photographs, prior threats, and the other person’s history can also provide the “some credible evidence” the statute requires.
Early Investigation
Video from homes, businesses, and phones is often overwritten within days. In a self-defense case, securing that evidence early can decide the outcome. Statements made to police before talking with a lawyer can also undercut a defense later, so see our post on police investigation tactics.
Working With a Colorado Springs Defense Lawyer
Attorney Michael W. Moran has been licensed to practice law in Colorado since 1995 and is a former municipal court judge. He represents people charged with assault, weapons, drug, and other offenses in El Paso, Teller, Pueblo, and Fremont counties, and in federal court in Colorado.
A first meeting covers what happened, whether an affirmative defense fits the facts, the evidence that needs to be preserved, and how the defense would affect trial and plea options. See our felony defense page and weapons charge page for more.
Criminal Defense Colorado Springs, P.C. offers free, confidential consultations.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who has the burden of proof on an affirmative defense in Colorado?
The prosecution. Once the defense is raised by some credible evidence, the prosecution must disprove it beyond a reasonable doubt, along with proving every element of the crime.
Does Colorado have a duty to retreat?
Colorado courts have held that a person who is not the initial aggressor generally has no duty to retreat before using reasonable force in self-defense.
Does the Make My Day law apply outside the house?
Generally, no. It applies to force used against someone who made an unlawful entry into a dwelling. Ordinary self-defense rules may still apply outside the home.
Is entrapment a common defense in sting cases?
It is raised often but succeeds only when officers induced someone who was not otherwise inclined to commit the offense. Simply offering an opportunity is not entrapment under Colorado law.
Can duress be a defense to murder in Colorado?
Duress is not a defense to a class 1 felony, which includes first-degree murder. It can apply to other offenses.
Is being drunk a defense in Colorado?
Voluntary intoxication is not a defense, though it can be relevant to whether a person formed a specific intent. Involuntary intoxication can be a complete defense.
What happens if someone is found not guilty by reason of insanity?
The person is committed to the Colorado Department of Human Services for treatment and is released only when a court finds they meet the legal requirements for release.

Author
Criminal Defense Attorney
Colorado Bar # 26337
Michael W. Moran has been licensed to practice law in Colorado since October 1995 and is a former municipal court judge. His practice focuses on criminal defense, including DUI and DUID, domestic violence, drug charges, juvenile cases, traffic offenses, and probation violations. He represents clients in El Paso, Teller, Pueblo, and Fremont counties. He earned his law degree from the University of Denver Sturm College of Law and is a member of the Colorado Bar Association, the El Paso County Bar Association, and the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. He is a member of the National College for DUI Defense and is rated Excellent on Avvo.
Last reviewed: November 10, 2026
Sources
- C.R.S. 18-1-407, Affirmative defense
- C.R.S. 18-1-702, Choice of evils
- C.R.S. 18-1-704, Use of physical force in defense of a person
- C.R.S. 18-1-704.5, Use of deadly physical force against an intruder
- C.R.S. 18-1-708, Duress
- C.R.S. 18-1-709, Entrapment
- C.R.S. 18-1-804, Intoxication
- C.R.S. 16-8-101.5, Insanity defined
- C.R.S. 16-8-105.5, Procedure after insanity plea
- HB25-1058, Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity Defense
